Empty thoughts and mutterings

Monday, December 05, 2005

Under appreciated Gems

I have always wanted to make a small list of songs that I thought were brilliant, but never made the charts because there were other songs in the same movie that took away all the popularity awards or were just not projected enough to get people's attention. I don't know if it's just me, but I have believed that the music directors are the real heroes in the movie and can make or break a movie with their performance. It is a shame, that some wonderful music has been grossly under utilized or ignored or horribly picturized in the 80's and 90's. Some directors/producers have no concept of how much creativity and hardwork it takes to create music. Raja took the brunt of the hits in all of these. Not that he ever let that deter him for his next performance. He kept coming up with some wonderful songs for some utterly stupid movies. I am not complaining because if he had decided to match the quality of his music to the quality (or lack of it) of the movie that he agreed to do, we wouldn't have been the beneficiary of all those timeless numbers. In a recent interview, Rahman was openly frustrated that some of his compositions for Period movies like "Earth" and "Legend of bhagat singh" were badly utilized and hence the true value of these compositions never came out. Although it was a little surprising that the calm and composed Rahman came out to the media with his frustration, the points that he put forward have to be respected. I don't mean to undermine everything else, but it is my opinion that composing music is probably the hardest part in making a movie and it is the director's responsibility to make sure that the work of the composer is projected the right way. And it is in turn the Music director's responsibility to spurn those directors who don't understand the value of the music or the effort that the composer has to put forth to have a decent album. And another reason that brillant directors like Manirathnam and Balachander are so reknowned is the fact that they use the music so well. While some wonderful songs, re-recordings and BGMs have come to the fore front either by their own merit, or by the sheer popularity of the actor/banner, some other "Dravid"esque performances, have been buried in the archives, by some of the above mentioned idiosyncrasies of the movie industry. Here are some of those songs that deserved to be better acknowledged in my opinion. Please suggest more songs that you think would fit this category.

"Naan paadum sandham" from Duet:

A classic from SPB and Kadri.Especially the part where he goes, vaazhkai oru duet adhile "inba thunbam irandum undu" where his voice gels with the sax, and there's an indistinguishable harmony. He sings at such a high pitch, that when you try to make that pitch, you feel stupid :). Sriram, remember your trip to akron, and how we listened to this like 15 times straight during the drive to cuyahoga falls/stow ? :)

"Anandham Anandham" from Muraimaaman:

Another classical beauty from the under rated Vidhyasagar. My respect for this man has been steadily growing, because of his endurance, quality of music and versatility. While he never gets mentioned in the "Best ever MDs in tamil" list, he's slowly sneaking up my charts for sure. This song was rendered beautifully by unnikrishnan and is a must listen to classical fans.

"Adi Nenthukitten Nenthukitten" from Star:

The one song that wasn't a remake from the Hindi movie Thakshak. And that's what happens to the one song in a movie where all other songs get remade. It gets forgotten ! Karthik makes a dream debut through this song ! Beautiful bhaavam and very pleasing naadhaswaram...Classic !

"Nathioram veesum thendral" from Alexander:

One beauty in a forgotten movie. Everything else deserved to be forgotten. It's hard to remember this song too, if all you've done is listen to it in passing, and you see Vijaykanth in an orange suit, dancing to this. This is another mellifluous unnikrishnan song with a beautiful classical touch.

"Arumbum Thalire" (Bhajan version) from Chandralekha:

I can't find this song in any of the music listings or archives. This is another of Raja's brilliant songs..Very soothing, pleasing song.

"Sollayo vaai thirandhu" from Moghamul:

A beautiful Shanmughapriya ! Sreekumar was excellent with this rendition.

"Poo poothathu" from Mumbai Express:

This is not really a completely forgotten song. I have it here because I thought this song was under appreciated. Wonderful use of the accoustic drums and the song in itself, had a beautiful flow and weaved a story from the start to the end. The genius of ilayaraja shines through !

"Vaan nila tharum" from Kaadhal Virus:

A late addition. Thanks Govind for reminding me about this song ! Terrific usage of the instruments to bring a "jazz" feel to the song. The transition at the start of the saranam to me was very pleasing. Loved karthik's voice in the song !

A lot more comes to mind. But I'll stop here for brevity's sake and yours :)

25 Comments:

  • hmmm, alexander/murai maamanaa?
    kettu paakaren...

    Nee iruntha varaikum lex la "under appreciated gem" aa iruntha vijay iniku "overu appreciate" panraanga ellarum!
    nee talent killer mattum illa, gem killer um nu oorula pesikaranga ;)

    By Blogger Prabhu, at 8:36 AM  

  • I love Film Music as much as anyone and you that Din,But Music is just one part of film making.

    Films have evolved and it so happens that Music has become an intricate part of Kollywood today.(Economical reasons being pre-dominant)Though I agree that some good songs go un-noticed in bad films , I could tell you countless songs which have become very popular , coz they had the right star acting or it was jus Picturised /choreographed well.

    And..Yeah..Music(specifically song composing) is not THE toughest part in Film Making..its right up there with Cinematography..Editing ..Lyric Writing(in terms of creative input)

    Whereas..Re-Recording is very tricky..the MD has to work hand-in-hand with the director to convey the mood of the scene.Sometimes the best RR is silence !!

    Writing a taut script with brilliant screenplay is THE toughest part.A good Screenplay can make a bad movie watchable ..even if it has the worst Music !!

    Good collection of Songs , though.

    Maybe you can add these two in as well..(Ones on top of my head)

    1)"Ila Nenjae Vaa" - Movie - Vanna Vanna Pookal

    2)"Thom Thom ThithiThom" - Movie - Alli Thantha Vaanam

    By Blogger Sayee, at 9:31 AM  

  • Was Sollayo Vaai Thiranthu under appreciated ? I thought all the songs from Mogamuzh were excellent and big hits. I loved 'em. And this song Nenthikitain comes into my favorite lists and takes you out of the world for sure. I never knew these songs were under appreciated ...

    -Vasu

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 10:01 AM  

  • dinesh,

    good and loveable post.

    i think "adi nenthukittEn" song was the only saving grace that made people to remember the kollywood movie star. it is not unappreciated, so is "nathiyOram veesum thenRal" of alexander (music by Karthik raja).

    as far as mumbai express songs are concerned it is really very sad to see that the songs sank along with the movie (ofcourse the movie deserved the drubbing). there is a splendid write-up on jazz by one Mr. Venkat and in one of the episodes he mentioned another jazz gem of mumbai express "kurangu kayyil maala". Here is the link: http://www.dhool.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=3760 read it.

    In my humble opinion vidhyasagar (VS) is nothing but sankar ganesh of current era (a bit overrated; but now and then comes-up with gem that resembles output of two geniuses of the reigning time. shankar-ganesh did that with MSV & IR and VS is doing with IR & ARR.

    If you love mohamuLL songs then you would love songs (except one) from 2004 movie called ponmekalai (music by ILayaraaja). You can listen it in MusicIndiaOnline site. There is one mellifluous duet "aalaapanai seyyum maalai pozhudhu" by Sadhana Sargam and Bhavatharini (if you can stand attrocious voice of Bhavatharini you will definitely appreciate this gem). This movie songs were not just underrated, they are never rated :)

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 9:44 PM  

  • Prabhu : Anaavasiyama ippdi pazhi sumathi enna oru villain range la project panre ! Ennamo po da maadhava !

    Sayee:

    I knew you'd do this..wasn't one bit of a surprise :). Okay I'll give you this..I don't know much about screenplay. I did think about the 0ther aspects though. Writing a good script and lyric writing for songs can be done well by people who are talented and still needs a good amount of effort (so does acting etc). But it is hard for me to visualize a field that is harder than CREATING music !

    By Blogger dinesh, at 9:02 AM  

  • This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    By Blogger dinesh, at 9:02 AM  

  • Vasu,

    Sollayo was not as appreciated as some of the other songs in the same movie. It was a subtle hit..and nenthukitten I thought was an exceptional song which a lot of people (music related even) still don't know.

    Sridhar:

    Thanks. Nadhioram was a song that I think only very few people know of. Listening to that song, I felt like if it had had happened in a higher profile movie, it had the makings of an "ennavale" or atleast "narumugaye". Equating Vidhyasagar to shankar ganesh ? Oh man, I have to disagree here..I am sure sayee, arun and sujan would too.. Vidhyasagar is highly under apppreciated I think and his versatility more than anything else has impressed me. Will listen to ponmekalai..thanks !

    By Blogger dinesh, at 9:07 AM  

  • Dinesh,

    NAlla collection

    Arumbum Thalire .. raaga.com la irukku ( movie listing -- Chandralekha)Enaku therinju indha padathula ella paatume excellent range.

    Alla un Anai padi
    Analthani Vaadum ( song perfectly suited for Bhavatharini .. kalakal rendering.. in my opinion)

    My favourite ( Panner Pushpangal -- Ananda Ragam, Kodai Kaala katrae, Poonthalir Aada) and Vaanengum Thanga Vinmeengal from Moondrampirai. I think not many people appreciate these songs.

    -vv


    prabhu ... adhu enna man oru nakkal ... ooruku pogara nerathula why this sindu mudiyara velai?

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 8:30 AM  

  • VV,

    Machi thanks !! ..

    Vaanengum vanna vinmeengal was the song I was searching for ! Great song..

    By Blogger dinesh, at 11:04 AM  

  • VV,

    Btw, Arumbum thalire in Raaga.com is not the Bhajan version. I was talking about the bhajan version

    By Blogger dinesh, at 11:28 AM  

  • For the uninitiated like me or well, partly initiated after my stay at lex, your list helps :)

    Good job!

    By Blogger RS, at 7:29 PM  

  • dinesh,
    unga posta padikarche neengale pesara maari irukku..
    alexander ellam naan kelviye pattadhu illa.. well, will listen sometime..

    By Blogger Maayaa, at 11:31 PM  

  • machi, two songs come flooding into my mind...

    - Kaadhal.. thana naana naana.. (the hum and tune) from the movie Kaadhal... totally went unnoticed... the audio is stunning, and I had a totally different visualization in my mind.. totally sodhappals...

    - Un Peyar Ennada - movie February 14, u might remember this song.. we listened to it together last time we met in Lex. The song runs through during the title credits...damn it.. I was really frustrated when I watched the movie.... the movie is total BS !!

    will think of some more and spam here.. :)

    By Blogger Zeppelin, at 1:24 PM  

  • RS - thanks ! :)

    Priya - Ennnaala avlo dhaan mudiyum. I am not like an RS or a Subha where they can write like "real" writers !!

    Zep - Kaadhal was not underappreciated da. I think it was reasonably known..the other song, I don;t remember da. Will listen to it when I get a chance !

    By Blogger dinesh, at 5:56 AM  

  • Add this, "Metti Oli Kaatrodu en nenjai thaalata..." padam peru theriyadhu. awesome number...

    Film Music is very important made to look very easy and simply by phenomenon's like IR. i still remember the awe with which Mani Ratnam spoke abbout IR in a function in landmark...

    But andha madhiri neraya skills irukku dinesh. i will write about one such today. very contemporary, and not respected just bcos of that.

    By Blogger expertdabbler, at 7:56 AM  

  • This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    By Blogger Sriks, at 10:47 AM  

  • Some wonderful songs for some utterly stupid movies.

    There are many reasons for this to happen. As soon the director gets the script ready and gets the "ok" from the producer, the first technical activity often in a movie production would be pooja and the song recording, Songs are composed well ahead of time within the script boundry.

    At this point of time, a script on paper will be clean and good, A Director will have all the hopes to execute the script.

    Over the Time most director face very many problems to make the script work. They will soon start compromising due to budget break downs, hero and other problems and these days, political problems  etc , adds up, often the script gets tinkered and it would not reflect what was it told to the composer on the day one.
    hence good song are wasted.

    Directors like Shankar, Mani ratham will not allow this to happen. They plan very well ahead of time - if you see songs are never wasted in their movies

    By Blogger Sriks, at 10:49 AM  

  • PK: Thanks ! I remember you mentioning lyric writing as one such in your blog. I am not saying Lyric writing is easy, but composing music is a much bigger effort in my opinion ! It requires a comprehensive skill set, starting from marketing skils, people skills, patience, talent and the list goes on.

    By Blogger dinesh, at 6:03 AM  

  • Sriks:

    Thanks for the music director's perspective :)

    Yeah, your theory for how the songs are wasted makes sense. I agree with you. Although you say this, in some of raja's works,it is hard to visualize that the movies had any kind of scope.

    By Blogger dinesh, at 6:07 AM  

  • There was a period in Tamil where directors would just go to “the king” and ask him compose something and then worry about deciding the script. King did his job to perfection but directors did not due to various reasons.

    IMHO, this was not a good trend; thank heavens it does not happen today. After all, movie is another method of for story telling, they are different from kathakalachebams, [another method of story telling]
    A Movie should never become a mere music video.


    யாரும் இருக்கும் இடத்தில் இருந்தால் எல்லம் Sowkiyame கருடன் சொன்னது..:)

    By Blogger Sriks, at 7:15 AM  

  • This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    By Blogger PH, at 12:41 PM  

  • Dinesh,

    Have you ever noticed that sometimes when you want to hum a song to yourself, the chart busters don't come to your mind; it's the "under appreciated gems" that you end up singing.

    Nice reference to ""Dravid"esque performances".

    By Blogger PH, at 12:48 PM  

  • Sriks,

    Agree with what's been said ! And yeah, I dont think the music's been taken for granted these days !

    PH,

    You are right. Subconsciously we pick up those "unsung" melodies !

    By Blogger dinesh, at 6:37 PM  

  • Dinesh- "Adi Nenthukitten Nenthukitten", "Nathioram veesum thendral" (Bhavatharini? awesome voice) and "Sollayo vaai thirandhu" were reasonably appreciated songs, IMHO. In fact, I love those songs.
    mathadhu ellam.. kettuttu solren.

    By Blogger Viji, at 3:44 AM  

  • By Blogger Unknown, at 5:59 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home